Fanny Meunier, William Marslen-Wilson, Mike Ford
MRC Cognition & Brain Sciences Unit, Cambridge
In English and using a cross-modal paradigm, Marslen-Wilson et al. (1994)
did not observe a priming effect between two suffixed words derived from
the same stem. They did however observe priming between a suffixed word
and its stem, a prefixed word and its stem, as well as between two prefixed
words derived from the same stem. For these authors, this lack of priming
between two suffixed words derived from the same stem reflects competition
processes between suffixed forms belonging to the same morphological family
when the common stem is accessed. In French, we observed that lexical decision
time associated with suffixed words presented auditorily depends on the
number of high-frequency suffixed candidates derived from the same stem
(Meunier & Segui, 1999). We interpreted this result in the framework
proposed by Marslen-Wilson et al. (1994) by postulating inhibitory processes
between suffixed words that share a stem.The aim of the present experiment
is to see whether or not, in French and using the same design and procedure
as Marslen-Wilson et al. (1994), we observe priming effects between two
suffixed words derived from the same stem. In French suffixed words can
be derived from different types of stem. It seems clear that the type of
stem can play a role on the way suffixed words are represented (decomposed
or not). Consequently in our experiment we study the priming effect observed
between two suffixed words depending on the type of stem they are derived
from. We contrasted three types of stem: free stems such as sport found
in sportif where the stem is a noun or an adjective; verbal free stems
such as attest- found in attestation where the stem can appear only as
verbal form, and bound stems such as ocul- found in oculaire where the
stem is not a word by itself. Suffixed words were presented visually as
targets in two auditory priming conditions: preceded either by another
suffixed word derived from the same stem or by a control prime. We also
had two control conditions: a suffixed word-stem condition and a formal
condition where primes and targets were formally related but not semantically
or morphologically related.We observed the classical suffixed word-stem
priming effect. And while no formal effect was observed, the results showed
a morphological priming effect for the three suffixed-suffixed word conditions:
suffixed word primes significantly facilitated lexical decision responses
for suffixed words whatever type of stem they were derived from. No interaction
was found, which means that the facilitatory effect did not differ with
the type of the stem. These results showed that, in French, suffixed words
derived from the same stem prime each other and that this morphological
effect is not modify by the type of stem these words are derived from.
The results obtained in French contrast with those observed in English.
This highlights the major role of the structure of languages on the way
words are lexically accessed and represented as well as the importance
of conducting experiments in different languages.
Full Paper
Bibliographic reference.
Meunier, Fanny / Marslen-Wilson, William D. / Ford, Mike (2000):
"Suffixed Word Lexical Representations in French",
In SWAP-2000, 31-34.
|